Opening verdict
Choose Permit, Review, Delay, or Prohibit before seeing comparison scores.
ILACE Conference Workshop · AUC 2026
AI Scores on Trial
A human-in-the-loop validity lab for writing assessment. Work from the text, test the score, and design a defensible human-review rule.
Participant tools
Everything you need—without a page-flip viewer
Open each resource directly. The essay is readable, the rubric is scorable, and your activity notes remain private on your device.
Read and mark the essay
Tap exact sentences to collect up to two evidence quotations for discussion.
Use the interactive rubric
Score your assigned dimension, record confidence, evidence, and uncertainty.
Complete the trial
Record your opening vote, group case, closing vote, and human-review trigger.
45-minute flow
Paper for depth. Phones for interaction.
The workshop stays face to face: discuss with people at your table, use the printed case for close reading, and use this site only where it adds speed or access.
Independent score
Score one rubric dimension and ground it in exact textual evidence.
Score on trial
Examine disagreement, make a claim, cite evidence, and name a limitation.
Review and revote
Write a measurable human-review rule, then give your final verdict.
Workshop resources
Prefer the complete paper case?
Download the participant case file for the essay, rubric, evidence record, micro-courtroom sheet, and exit rule in one printable document.